Treasure Hunt Central
On my TikTok (@marissainspires) I recently asked the question “Where are your favorite spots to thrift in the 315?” and the response was OVERWHELMING! So I’ve put together a list we can all reference for places in Central New York. Since we all have our own definition of “thrift” - the list is a mix of thrifts, consignment, antique malls - I’m not going to discriminate, pick what looks good to you! These spots have not been verified, so do your own research!
Alexandria Bay:
Alexandria Bay Community Thrift Store
Adams Center:
Rescue Mission
Rescued Treasures
Auburn:
Grandma Jaree’s
Regenerations
Reuse Refuge
Salvation Army
Sew What (Sewing & Knitting supplies)
Thrifty Shopper
Baldwinsville:
Thrifty Shopper
Barneveld:
Foothills Mercantile
The Walk-In Closet
Blossvale:
Weedens Mini Mall
Brewerton:
At The Farm
Pandora’s Barn
Camden:
Cluster 13
Camillus:
3Fifteen
Canastota:
Opportunity Shop
Pot Luck Thrift
Red Barn Antique
Canton:
The Rabbit Hole
Central Square:
Devine Mersey Church (Tue/Thu 9am-12pm)
RestoreNY
Chittenango:
Monkey See Monkey Do (funds monkey rescue!)
Salvation Army
Yellowbrick Thrift
Cicero:
Goodwill
Thrifty Shopper
Clayville:
Sauquoit Valley Friends
Clinton:
Consignment Chic
Dawn Marie Treasures
Recycling In Style
Thriftish
Constantia:
Constantia United Methodist Chruch Thrift Shop
The Red Barn
Copenhagen:
United Church (Saturdays only)
Cortland:
ReUse
Thrifty Shopper
Dolgeville:
Stella’s Styles
Elbridge:
Elbridge Community Church
Fly Creek:
Christine’s Upscale Resale Consignment
Fulton:
Catholic Charities
Oswego County SPCA (basement of Methodist Church, proceeds pets)
Re-Tails (proceeds pets)
Salvation Army
Geneva:
Center of Concern
Penny Lane
Salvation Army
Gouverneur:
Picker’s Dream
Railroad Market
Great Bend:
Great Bend Methodist Church
Hamilton:
Worn Again (inside Parry’s)
Herkimer:
Arc Herkimer Goods Store
Renewed & Rescued
Ilion:
Cornerstone Shop
Morning Star United Methodist Church
Pay It Forward
Jamesville:
Sweet Salvage
Little Falls
Kateries Church Thrift
Liverpool:
Thrifty Shopper
Salvation Army
Lyons:
Helpful Hearts
Lyons Falls:
Forrest Finds Church Thrift
Marcellus:
Marcellus Methodist Church
Marcellus Mercantile
Rummage Haven
Rummage Too
Massena:
Fabulous Finds
Massena Marketplace
Mexico:
Our Care & Share Thrift Shop
Mohawk:
Mohawk Antique Mall
Newark:
Angels Attic (proceeds local hospice)
Arcadia Thrift
Tom’s Bargain Shop
New Hartford:
Mariah’s Closet
Thrifty Shopper
Village Basement
North Rose:
Wesley Chruch Thrift Shop (Fri & Sat only)
North Syracuse:
Cradle & Beyond
Kid to Kid
Thrifty Shopper
Oneida:
Eclectic Chic
Odd & Old Antique
Mine & Consign (W-Fr 11-4, Sa 11-2)
Worthy
Oswego:
Port City Co-Op
Second Chances (mostly free)
Thrifty Shopper
Palermo:
Second Chance Church Thrift
Palmyra:
Palmyra Flea Market
Smitten Collective
Penn Yann:
Once Again
Thrifted Threads
Phoenix:
Little Utica Methodist Church
Potsdam:
Best Friends Thrift Shop (Humane Society)
North Country Neighbors (Flea)
Thriftique
Thrifty Treasures
Pulaski:
Riverside Boutique
UFHA Thrift Store
Red Creek:
Wesley Church Thrift Store
Rome:
Berrys Babies (children clothes)
Thrifty Shopper
Trunk & Treasure
Salvation Army
Sandy Creek:
Friendship ThriftShop
Seneca Falls:
Thrifty Shopper
Sherril:
Worth Repeating
Skaneateles:
Mottville Consignment & Emporium
St James Thrift Shop
Syracuse:
3Fifteen (Eastwood)
3Fifteen (SU Hill)
Antiques West (Downtown)
Beyond the Iron Gates (TippHill)
Clothes Mentor (Dewitt)
Cluttered Closet (Westcott)
Eco Chic (Dewitt)
Encore Thrift (Fayetteville - proceeds to Syracuse Symphony)
Fashion Exchange (Fayetteville)
Gideon’s Gallery
Goodwill (West side)
Kia Foundation (James St, proceeds pets)
Priscilla’s Thrift (funds animals)
Salvation Army
St. Matthew’s Chrurch (East Syr)
St. Lucy Church (Gifford St, Weds 9am-12:30pm)
Syracuse Antiques Exchange
Thrifty Shopper (East Syracuse)
Thrifty Shopper (Westvale Plaza)
Thrifty Shopper (Valley)
Tully:
Country Peddler
Utica:
The Birds Nest
Utica Creative Reuse (craft supplies)
Verona:
Purple Flamingo Thrift & Gift
Watertown:
Salvation Army
State Street Market
Thrifted
Thrifty Shopper
Trendy’s Discount Fashionwear & Accessories
Waterloo:
Next to New (children clothing)
Waterville:
Pass It On
Westmoreland:
Bittersweet Pines
Williamson:
Come-Unity Shop
Whitesboro:
The Boutique on Main St
Thread of Life Thrift Store
Yorkville:
The Queens Closet