Treasure Hunt Central

On my TikTok (@marissainspires) I recently asked the question “Where are your favorite spots to thrift in the 315?” and the response was OVERWHELMING! So I’ve put together a list we can all reference for places in Central New York. Since we all have our own definition of “thrift” - the list is a mix of thrifts, consignment, antique malls - I’m not going to discriminate, pick what looks good to you! These spots have not been verified, so do your own research!

Alexandria Bay:

  • Alexandria Bay Community Thrift Store

Adams Center:

  • Rescue Mission

  • Rescued Treasures

Auburn:

  • Grandma Jaree’s

  • Regenerations

  • Reuse Refuge

  • Salvation Army

  • Sew What (Sewing & Knitting supplies)

  • Thrifty Shopper

Baldwinsville:

  • Thrifty Shopper

Barneveld:

  • Foothills Mercantile

  • The Walk-In Closet

Blossvale:

  • Weedens Mini Mall

Boonville:

  • Matthew’s Place

Brewerton:

  • At The Farm

  • Pandora’s Barn

Camden:

  • Cluster 13

Camillus:

  • 3Fifteen

Canastota:

  • Opportunity Shop

  • Pot Luck Thrift

  • Red Barn Antique

Canton:

  • The Rabbit Hole

Central Square:

  • Devine Mersey Church (Tue/Thu 9am-12pm)

  • RestoreNY

Chittenango:

  • Monkey See Monkey Do (funds monkey rescue!)

  • Salvation Army

  • Yellowbrick Thrift

Cicero:

  • Goodwill

  • Thrifty Shopper

Clayville:

  • Sauquoit Valley Friends

Clinton:

  • Consignment Chic

  • Dawn Marie Treasures

  • Recycling In Style

  • Thriftish

Constantia:

  • Constantia United Methodist Chruch Thrift Shop

  • The Red Barn

Copenhagen:

  • United Church (Saturdays only)

Cortland:

  • ReUse

  • Thrifty Shopper

Dolgeville:

  • Stella’s Styles

Elbridge:

  • Elbridge Community Church

Erieville

  • The Shoppes at Johnny Appleseed

Fly Creek:

  • Christine’s Upscale Resale Consignment

Fulton:

  • Catholic Charities

  • Eclectic Thrift

  • Oswego County SPCA (basement of Methodist Church, proceeds pets)

  • Re-Tails (proceeds pets)

  • Salvation Army

Geneva:

  • Center of Concern

  • Geneva Antique Co-Op

  • Penny Lane

  • Salvation Army

Gouverneur:

  • Picker’s Dream

  • Railroad Market

Great Bend:

  • Great Bend Methodist Church

Hamilton:

  • Worn Again (inside Parry’s)

Herkimer:

  • Arc Herkimer Goods Store

  • Mohawk Valley Community Market

  • Renewed & Rescued

Ilion:

  • Cornerstone Shop

  • Morning Star United Methodist Church

  • Pay It Forward

Jamesville:

  • Sweet Salvage

Little Falls

  • Kateries Church Thrift

  • Moss Island

Liverpool:

  • Thrifty Shopper

  • Salvation Army

Lyons:

  • Helpful Hearts

Lyons Falls:

  • Forrest Finds Church Thrift

Marcellus:

  • Marcellus Methodist Church

  • Marcellus Mercantile

  • Rummage Haven

  • Rummage Too

Massena:

  • Fabulous Finds

  • Massena Marketplace

Mexico:

  • Our Care & Share Thrift Shop

Mohawk:

  • Mohawk Antique Mall

Moravia:

  • Haus of Hamilton

Newark:

  • Angels Attic (proceeds local hospice)

  • Arcadia Thrift

  • Tom’s Bargain Shop

New Hartford:

  • Mariah’s Closet

  • Thrifty Shopper

  • Village Basement

North Rose:

  • Wesley Chruch Thrift Shop (Fri & Sat only)

North Syracuse:

  • Cradle & Beyond

  • Kid to Kid

  • Thrifty Shopper

Oneida:

  • Eclectic Chic

  • Odd & Old Antique

  • Mine & Consign (W-Fr 11-4, Sa 11-2)

  • Worthy

Oriskany Falls

  • Community Creekside Outreach

Oswego:

  • Port City Co-Op

  • Second Chances (mostly free)

  • Thrifty Shopper

Palermo:

  • Second Chance Church Thrift

Palmyra:

  • Palmyra Flea Market

  • Smitten Collective

Penn Yann:

  • Once Again

  • Thrifted Threads

Phoenix:

  • Little Utica Methodist Church

Potsdam:

  • Best Friends Thrift Shop (Humane Society)

  • North Country Neighbors (Flea)

  • Thriftique

  • Thrifty Treasures

Pulaski:

  • Riverside Boutique

  • UFHA Thrift Store

Red Creek:

  • Wesley Church Thrift Store

Rome:

  • Berrys Babies (children clothes)

  • Thrifty Shopper

  • Trunk & Treasure

  • Turin Road Treasures

  • Salvation Army

Sandy Creek:

  • Angus Hill Flea Market

  • Friendship ThriftShop

Seneca Falls:

  • Thrifty Shopper

Sherril:

  • Worth Repeating

Skaneateles:

  • Mottville Consignment & Emporium

  • St James Thrift Shop

Syracuse:

  • 3Fifteen (Eastwood)

  • 3Fifteen (SU Hill)

  • Antiques West (Downtown)

  • Beyond the Iron Gates (TippHill)

  • Clothes Mentor (Dewitt)

  • Cluttered Closet (Westcott)

  • Eco Chic (Dewitt)

  • Encore Thrift (Fayetteville - proceeds to Syracuse Symphony)

  • Fashion Exchange (Fayetteville)

  • Gideon’s Gallery

  • Goodwill (West side)

  • Kia Foundation (James St, proceeds pets)

  • Priscilla’s Thrift (funds animals)

  • Re’Cuse (3235 W Genesee St Th-Sat 11-4pm)

  • Regional Market (Flea Market Sundays)

  • Salvation Army

  • St. Matthew’s Chrurch (East Syr)

  • St. Lucy Church (Gifford St, Weds 9am-12:30pm)

  • Syracuse Antiques Exchange

  • Thrifty Shopper (East Syracuse)

  • Thrifty Shopper (Westvale Plaza)

  • Thrifty Shopper (Valley)

Thendera

  • Eats ‘N Tiques

Tully:

  • Country Peddler

Utica:

  • The Birds Nest

  • Utica Creative Reuse (craft supplies)

Verona:

  • Purple Flamingo Thrift & Gift

Watertown:

  • Salvation Army

  • State Street Market

  • Thrifted

  • Thrifty Shopper

  • Trendy’s Discount Fashionwear & Accessories

  • Urban Mission (Factory St)

Waterloo:

  • Next to New (children clothing)

  • Penny Lane

Waterville:

  • Pass It On

Weedsport

  • Kathleen’s Attic

Westmoreland:

  • Bittersweet Pines

Williamson:

  • Come-Unity Shop

Whitesboro:

  • The Boutique on Main St

  • Thread of Life Thrift Store

Yorkville:

  • The Queens Closet